Too dry, doesn't apply smoothly over the eyelid and the colour flakes right off. It also says waterproof which it isn't since it rubs right off the skin leaving no colour behind. When I even twisted it to 'self sharpen' a chunk of the eyeliner broke off. I bought this because I bought other Annabelle eyeliners that worked well and thought this would too. Big disappointment.

Keep the lid so you can keep it sharp. I hate sharpeners and shavings in my makeup bag so, this is a great option. The quality has decreased in recent years but I'm still addicted. Can't live without it. Great for low maintenance people like me.

I find this eyeliner very easy to apply. The pencil is always sharp and makes a nice subtle line. I use the colour Graphite which works well for me. This eyeliner scores "excellent" on the Yuka app which is very important to me and Annabelle is a also Canadian company🇨🇦👍

I wanted a purple kohl liner, I thought this colour looked nice so I bought it on a whim. It's the worst eyeliner I have ever used in my life. It's dry as heck, it just skips across your eyelid leaving ugly little chunks of pigment. You definitely can't smudge or blend it because #1 it didn't even apply in the first place and #2 it just disappears instantly (whatever chunks actually did somehow get onto your skin). There's no way you could use this in your waterline, it would do absolutely nothing. I tried it multiple times for some reason hoping it would work and I just threw it out today. 110% do not buy, it's literally unusable.