This product works really well as soon as it is fresh out of the box however it does dry out very quickly but does reactivate if you add a little water . the consistency is really good it's thick but still liquidy it is enough that if you do make an error you're able to correct it an application is very easy.

This eyeliner is the BEST! It's my ride or die. It's waterproof and smudge proof. It will last all day and all night. Dries quickly and is super easy to remove.

Good packing and easy to open. Dries fast and good and easy yo use. Doesnt smear and waterproof too. Easy to put in with eyebrush. Would recommend.

I've been using this eyeliner for a few weeks now and it's one of the best liquid liners I've tried at this price point. The brush tip is super precise and makes it really easy to draw sharp wings.

The packaging quality is good. The drying time takes like 20 sec which is good. The sensitivity test was okay on the skin. The application is very easy even when you learn how to do eyeliner. I like how it's water resistance so like water don't get it wet.

The second half was a lot better than I thought it should have been because the first one is so much more interesting to me because it was the second

Liquid liner is too thin and after a few uses it started to clump and dry up. The bristles started separating in the bottle and thinning making the application look a clumpy mess. Comes off with the slightest tears so it's definitely not waterproof.

It was ok in the beginning of a few hours, later on the eyes liner started blurry and my eyes look like panda eyes, very embarrassed!

This eyeliner is unfortunately everything i want to avoid. Its streaky thin not precise and you can literally feel it dried on your eyelid. As you can see in the swatches a single line is patchy and not at all fully black. If you do more layers it finally gets color payoff but its STILL streaky and becomes uncomfortably thick and dry. You cannot get a sharp wing with this! Its super cheap but seriously just spend a bit more and get a quality liner. Now i am on the hunt for another black eyeliner as this is a complete miss

Brush is too stiff - Takes long to dry. Product runs and smudges easily.