I am very serious about my eye products and I was so excited to receive Bobbi Brown's 24 Hour Kajal Eyeliner in black. I took my time to test out this eyeliner because I know how tedious eye makeup can be. One mistake and you have to start again. The eyeliner went on smooth the first time I used it but not as smooth the second time. I only tested it out on my top eyelid only, as I try not to do too much eye makeup when at work. I got lots of compliments because it made my lashes look fuller. I accidentally touched my face with dampened hands after washing my hands and the eyeliner stayed in place. I have oily eyelids and it still remained intact. I'm not sure that I would purchase this again because I felt like it was harder to apply after a few days. This tells me that this isn't a good product to use long term because I felt like I was tugging my eyelid too much. I received this product for free from Bobbi Brown for testing and review purposes.

This is very smooth and easy to apply and the color is vibrant and very long lasting. I am highly impressed. I received this product for free from Bobbi Brown for testing and review purposes.

Application-wise, I had to go over the same area several times as it does apply a bit patchy. It doesn't make for a crisp cat-eye but it still looked good to me. The navy was more apparent when I was applying it, but zoomed out, it looks pretty black to me. I have oily lids and was worried if it would smudge throughout the day. It didn't smudge but it did start to flake onto my top and bottom lids near the end of the day. So if you are only going out for a short bit, this is great. If you have a long day and have oily lids, your eyeliner is going to look patchy and there will be flakes around your eyes. I received this product for free from Bobbi Brown for testing and review purposes.

Bobbi Brown 24 Hour Kajal Liner was very easy to apply. I love how smoothly the eyeliner glided across my eyelids without any tugging. The color was dark and bold, and it lasted all day without smudging or needing to be reapplied, which I really liked. When it was time to remove the eyeliner, I needed makeup remover to take off the remaining product. It is definitely waterproof, and it shows! I love that I can count on this eyeliner to last throughout the day without having to worry about touching it up.

I was gifted this product in exchange for review purposes and I am very excited to try it. This kajal eyeliner is waterproof and can last up to twenty four hours. This product glides on smoothly. It doesn't smudge at all. The consistency of the product is great. The color is very bold and beautiful. I definitely would recommend this item.

I love this Navy Blue waterprood eyeliner. I used it for several hours and it stayed in place. I love how easy it was to apply to the waterline and eyelid. I blended it to avoid the harsh line and that you do need to blend relatively fast. The eyeliner from the waterline didn't transfer to the upper lid like other eyeliners I use.

I wore the Bobbi Brown 24 Hour Kajal Waterproof Eyeliner every day for a week, and was sadly disappointed by its performance. The eyeliner pencil is highly pigmented and a goes on very dark black with just one sweep; some people may like this but found that it was hard to lightly build, and immediately left me with a thick dark goth-like look on my eyes. Furthermore, I noticed that throughout the day pigmented would transfer and smudge to my under eyes and I would develop "raccoon eyes". However, it was then difficult to remove, even with makeup remover - so it's definitely waterproof, but highly smudge-able. I sharpened it with my normal makeup pencil sharpener and found that it just caused pieces to crumble into my lashes when applied. Overall, I'd give this product 1/5 stars. I received this product for free from Bobbi Brown for testing and review purposes.

I work in a hot and humid environment and have had issues with all my eyeliners until now. This liner is amazing, no running or smudging for my whole day. Glides on nice and smooth and the black is beautiful. I received this product for free from Bobbi Brown for testing and review purposes.

Bobbi Brown 24HR Kajal Eyeliner looks amazing no matter what look you are doing. The color has high pigmentation and does not fade even after a long day. The application is so smooth every time and very precise. I currently use the black and I am excited to try the other options.

This eyeliner is stunning! It's a beautiful shade that's highly pigmented. It glides on smooth and doesn't pull at the skin around my eyes. I love that it doesn't smudge easily and stays in place all day long. This is my new go to eyeliner! / received this product for free from Bobbi Brown for testing and review purposes.