I really like the colors of these eyeliners & bought several, but I've had at least 2 fall out of the holder when trying to use it. Sad.

I loved this liner; however, more than 1/4 inch of the pointed end broke off, so the portion that was left was too thick to get a nice thin line of liner on my eye lids. I would like to order another but feel it's a waste of money.

Finally found an item I liked (bought 5 different pieces). Great pigment, LOVE the way it goes on and it is long wearing! Very happy so far. I am worried though about being able to sharp it correctly as others have stated.

Really wanted to love this product. I love how it glides on, but sadly the "built in sharpener" they mention doesn't work, at least in my opinion. The end becomes to thick and round so it doesn't really work as a liner for me anymore.

Unfortunately the Panther liner's tip arrived broken off when I opened it directly from the box. You can see in the photo what the brand new Fog liner looked like (on the right) — nicely shaped pointed tip. Whereas the Panther (on the left) had the entire pointed tip broken off, so much so that the product that I twisted out of the tube was just flat and jagged. Not sure how I'm going to even sharpen that to begin using it.

Panther is just what I was looking for in a bold, very black eyeliner.

It's a beautiful pencil, stays on all day but doesn't last long in a tube. Began using it about 5-6 months ago and now it's dry, crumbly and broke at half way point. Really wish it would last as long as eyeshadow pencils. Some are 4-5 years old and still going strong

Love the color and its staying power once applied, but the "stick" gets blunt quickly, and no longer functions as a pointy stick, which was what I was looking for. And after sometime, the color no longer glides on smoothly - you need to really press it on the eye lid to get the color. But once on, it stays on. I hope BB can improve the way this product works.

I have the fog, panther and olive. They go on very smoothly. Love the way they look. However, they do not last and fade. Very quickly they disappear even with powder over. It is a shame. Colors are great. Also both the fog and panther have lids that do not stay on. It'll pop off in my makeup bag and get all over. We just need liners that set down and last like the pot gel liners.

I really wanted to love this waterproof eyeliner—when it works, it delivers a smooth, long-lasting application with great pigmentation. Unfortunately, I experienced an issue after just a couple of uses: the entire pencil came out of the casing on the second try. It seems like I'm not alone, as other reviews mention similar problems. It's such a shame because the formula itself is fantastic and it wears well throughout the day. Hopefully, this is just a quality control issue, and I'd love to see the design improved. For now, I'm hesitant to recommend since it's not just me!