Love this mask I have nice individual lashes not clumped together like other brands.

Been using this mascara for 10+ years and its my favorite! Yes, it is trickier to remove, but the price im willing to pay for it to stay on all day and never any flaking or racoon eyes. I find basic baby oil has been the best at removing

Used to be my fave mascara, would stay put all day no matter how many tears and now it streaks like any other mascara. RAAHHHHH

This mascara used to stay put all day, but over the past few months both of my last two tubes have started smudging and leaving black circles under my eyes. I thought the first tube was defective, but the second did the same thing. It really seems like the formula has changed. I work a regular office job, so there's no sweating or humidity involved, and I've since switched to a different brand because it no longer performs the way it used to.

I am very active, love being outdoors and do lots of varying sports, work, etc. in changing temperatures. I may start my day outside in 90+ heat and end at work with -20 temps. This is the only mascara I have found that resists smudging and holds up throughout the whole day. It is fantastic and the only one I will wear. Perfect for my sensitive eyes too.

This was my go to waterproof mascara for years. Now within a couple of hours, I have black under my eyes and on top my eyelid? What did you do Clinique??? Why would you change a great product? You must have for it to not work anymore...very disappointed.

This used to be my favorite mascara for years. It stayed on through anything and never smudged, even if I slept in it! Recently however, it seems as if the quality has gone way down. It barely lasts through the day and smudges SO easily, I end most days with raccoon eyes. Definitely not waterproof anymore! Has the formula changed? It feels so much cheaper, less glossy and much thinner. I'm so disappointed.

I love this mascara! It really accentuates my long eyelashes and keeps me looking fresh and perky, even when I am working hard in a cross-country meet or working it in the middle of a dance floor!

I had the opportunity to try the Clinique Waterproof Mascara through this trial. It gave my lashes a soft, natural look and felt very lightweight—my lashes never felt heavy or stiff while wearing it. While it didn't provide as much volume as I usually get from some other mascaras, it worked well for a more subtle, everyday style. If you prefer a mascara that enhances your lashes while still looking natural and comfortable to wear, this could be a great option. I received this product for free from Clinique for testing and review purposes.

Love this mascara! Even held up for my daughter's wedding. Does not flake or smudge.