What a waste of money!!! It works fine till you try and sharpen it...good luck! I would never buy it again and I highly recommend getting a different product.

This is a great pencil, easy to apply, nice and soft...until you have to sharpen it. it is encased in hard plastic. it would be so much better if it was a mechanical pencil style (so that the eyeliner is not wasted) or, at least encased in wood. now i'm so frustrated because i can't get rid of sharp points that hurt my eyelids when i'm trying to apply it. my sharpener is quite ineffective. I'm seriously considering discarding it completely.

Impossible to apply to eyes. In fact it hurts to apply. Draws fine on hand. Awful product.

I bought this about two months ago. I didn't know that the pencil had to be sharpened . I love the way the product goes on however the pencil is hard to sharpen. I have a dual sharpener and it's awful. With me trying to sharpen it, the product crumbles in the sharpener. I probably won't purchase this again.

This goes on easily but doesn't stay put! After about an hour, it's smudged in the crease of my eyelids, and then after about another hour, it flakes off! Waste of money!

I bought it today and it broke, would not recommend to anyone

Eyeliner pencil . It is absolutely horrible to sharpen! Why not make it mechanical? I sharpen it and the go to use and it breaks off! No matter how little or big the point is…..

Love the eyeliner itself. Wasted 1/2 of it sharpening the darn thing. The liner part kept breaking and i have a good sharpener. Waste of money.

After only two or three uses, it's ready for the garbage. There is no way to twist it for more product!!! What you see is ALL you get. Horribly expensive for that reason.

Liked the smoothness of the eyeliner but the sharpening did not work. Expensive for the limited amount of product. Will not buy again.