I'm a long-time E.L.F. user and this mascara missed the mark. It runs everytime I use it, leaving me looking like I have been crying. It might be the first product I completely loathe.

it's good (plus vegan + cruelty free!) but does get a little chunky which is difficult

I get a lot of compliments on my eye lashes when I use this mascara. My only con is the flakiness that begins a few hours after applying.

I bought the travel size of this mascara for in my purse and I keep taking out to use instead of my other mascara! I'll have to get the normal version

Really disappointed with this mascara. Very clumpy application and it smudges under the eyes very quickly leaving me looking like a panda.

Color tried: Black. I've never been a mascara fan because every one I've previously tried looked clumpy and made my eyes feel tired. Decided to give this one a try though because of the brush design and was impressed! Pros: Emphasizes eyelashes with minimal clumping. The little bit of clumping there is can be combed out with an eyelash comb. Does not tire my eyes at all! So comfortable I can almost forget I'm wearing it. The full size fits just fine in my travel makeup pouch; I'm honestly a little confused why this got a travel size version. Mascara stays put during wear, no escaping into my undereye and making me look (more) tired. Mixed: Very washable – washes off completely with only my gentle water-based cleanser, no scrubbing or double cleansing needed (although you can remove it with cleansing oil as well). It also gets removed by the wet cotton swabs I use to clean up mascara smears if I don't squeeze excess water out of them first. I have not worn this product in the rain or while crying yet, but I would predict a mess. 100% worth it to me as someone whose skin is too sensitive to double cleanse more than twice a week or to withstand a bunch of eye scrubbing. Cons: Does clump a little as previously mentioned, but that's easily fixed with a comb. Flakes a little bit as well, but I only notice this during application, and thankfully the flakes can be readily removed with a wet fingertip or cotton swab. Would recommend applying this product before anything else on your face or eyes so you're not also wiping off makeup you want to stay on your skin. Overall I am very happy with this mascara and would like to continue using it, which is not something I ever thought I'd say about a mascara. I have a sinking feeling this one is on its way out though because it's become increasingly more difficult to find in physical stores here. If it continues to be offered when my current tube runs out or expires, I would like to try the brown version next.

This by far has the perfect brush. It's not to big, & not to small yet your separats lashes for a great spread. Not clumpy, & the more you use it the prettier it make your eyes as the formula holds great on your lashes. Not flakey at all. It definitely adds definition,volume,& LENGTH. My all time favorite!!! Love the travel size also. It isn't waterproof yet that's what I like anyway!!!

This mascara absolutely is a MUST HAVE and I love travel size easily slides in my purse so I have big mood too..but this one doesn't clump thickens the length and more

This mascara is amazing! Seriously lengthens my lashes instantly.

I received a free travel size version of this and it's literally the best mascara I have tried! It lifts, curls, separates, AND lengthens my lashes. This product is very easy to apply and take off < 3