I have used this brand for years. But my last two tubes have been clumpy and it flakes off throughout the day. This will be my last tube.

have used it twice and am throwing it away. it is so flaky, im getting so much mascara in my contacts and around my face. i lost a contact in class rubbing my eye from the irritation. further, do NOT use false lashes on top of this mascara. i've worn strip lashes daily for 8 years and use the same glue regularly without problems. after using this mascara, the lash glue seemed to bond to the mascara and I couldn't remove the lash — even oil around the base of the lash didn't loosen it. I had to scrub it off and ruined the lash. This has never happened before, so the mascara must be the issue. really disappointed

I love this mascara, my lashes always look full and long

This mascara is not at all what I would normally wear. I know it's waterproof but it's almost impossible to get off. In addition, it doesn't lengthen my lashes like other products by Essence.

Really really good it hurts to take off if you don't use makeup remover

I have short, blonde tipped eyelashes, and hooded eyes, so that's basically three strikes against me going in. I've tried so many mascaras, and they either don't really lengthen, they smudge, etc. I do prefer waterproof mascara, just cause. So, I found this- waterproof, vegan, cruelty free, and decent price- and decided to try it. WELL. This mascara is amazing!!! My eyelashes are actually visible, they're super long, and there's little to no smudging at all! This has definitely become a go-to product for me. The only reason I gave it 4 stars is because it's hard to get off. I use makeup remover cloths (not wipes) and while they remove other waterproof makeup, they don't do anything for this stuff, so I do need to use an extra waterproof makeup remover. Otherwise, definitely 5 stars!

Who needs falsies?! This mascara may dry up a little quicker than others, but for the cost of it… and the amazing feel and look of it… you can totally afford to replace it more often. You SHOULD replace your mascara every 3 months ANYWAY! This stuff is the bomb diggity! Blows my mind, every single day! 🤗

I am a return customer and I absolutely love the Princess false lash effect. By far the best mascara I've ever used.

I've been pretty happy about Essence products thus far but I was disappointed by this mascara. It looks great for the first couple of hours but I could clearly see it was starting to smudge after that, especially on my lower lashes, and was not flattering. It didn't look terrible but I went with a different brand that cost about the same after using this a couple of times and not liking the results.

This mascara is amazing! I use it during school and it's the best one I have tried so far I Coukd not recommend this any more it makes my lashes look amazing and super long and it isn't nearly as clumpy as my old one!