I love this eyeliner - I have used it for years and will continue to use. The fine brush makes application very easy and it removes beautifully.

I used to use this product years ago and then tried other premium brands, I have now gone back to this product as it is the best on the market, Intense colour that stays and glides on with the brush. I put 2 coats on to get the intense colour. Will purchase again.

Not sure how its getting such great reviews or if my bottle is defective but seems like there is no stopper that scrapes the excess product off of the wand or its absolutely terrible at it. The brush short and thin so your lashes will probably touch the wand part when drawing your line, and because of all the extra product on the wand itself, a huge bead of product will transfer to your lashes. You cant scrape it along the side or anything either. I have short lashes and its such a huge problem I dont use this at all. The formula itself isnt bad, I adore the bottle but it really feels like either mine was broken or something was terribly overlooked.

I've been using this eyeliner for years and it was absolutely fantastic so I had no doubts what eyeliner to buy when it was time to buy new one. But unfortunately it's not like it was before- now it's doesn't have the same intense colour- so you need to use more of the product. And the quality is not the same- it's still ok but not as good as it used to be. I only decided to leave the review because It's said that it guarantees 24 hours wear(!!!). NO. ITS NOT ANYMORE. I would say it used to guarantee that, but now it's crumbling on the corner of the eye.

This is a really good liquid eyeliner. Easy to use, lasts all day and doesn't smudge.

I absolutely adore everything about this liquid eyeliner! I am in my 50s and have been using liquid eyeliner pretty much every day since I was 15, so have a lot of product research under my belt! What I love about this is that it is a traditional bottle and brush. The brush is perfectly thin and the liquid is a perfect consistency. The bottle itself is the most stylish makeup bottle I have ever owned. It sits on my shelf as it is way too pretty to be in a bag. Thank you, Guerlain for continuing to make a traditional product that is chic, classic, and absolutely gorgeous.

I choose this product from so many out on the market hoping that is up to the reviews and I have to say I am extremely unhappy with the product. It dry so hard is coming off so easily. I am so unhappy with it. How is possible to have so good reviews?

I'm born with very, very oily skin. So, I've been trying out almost EVERY eyeliner product that claims to last (you name it, even including popular Asian brands). Most of them smudge into different forms and end up on my lower eyelids. Until recently I heard about this one. Let me be clear, it is NOT waterproof; in fact, it is quite sensitive to water, even your finger -- you rub it, it is gone. BUT, in exchange for its lack of power against water and rubbing, it is completely oil-proof. No matter how shiny my eyelids get, it stays there, in its original color, and in its original shape. If you also have oily skin, you sohuld know how hard this is. Give it a try! I bought another black bottle after I tried the brown.

I bought this 3 weeks ago, it is not intense. When I tried the sample, it was great and intense but mine is not. It dried for 30 seconds so after applying you should wait for a bit. But the color is great.

Bought this a few weeks ago in brown. Very easy to be draw a thin or more dominant line. It's not Matt so doesn't look too harsh. Would be nice in burgundy.