This product is very good. The only thing I do have to say is that it's not smudge proof. It's very creamy and glides on nicely. It's also very pigmented.

I can't ever find an eyeliner that stays in my waterline because my eyes tear a lot. However, the stage proof eyeliner goes on smoothly and stays put! The only eyeliner that works for me!

I love this eyeliner so much, it is very long lasting and works very well for tight lining my eyes. Because of its size, it's also very versatile and it's my go to pick when doing long lasting eye makeup

Absolutely LOVED this eyeliner, it's the perfect cobalt shade. It's heavily pigmented so I typically only need one coat, which is rare with pencil liners. It's a soft texture, so it goes on extremely smoothly! 10/10 would recommend!

I really loved the color of this eyeliner and it went on really smoothly (almost too smooth!). But, i didnt feel like it had a lot of longevity nor staying power. Color kind of faded and easily smudged. I have pretty sensitive eyes, so this is probably more personal of my experience but it did make my eyes sting when washing it off.

I was surprised at the staying power of this eyeliner, especially for a pencil. Water and scrubbing barely budged it, I needed a makeup removing balm. Whatever coating is on the product initially made me think the color was quite light, but after getting through the first layer it was actually a rich brown. The pencil is on the softer side so not for a thin precise application.

I was pleasantly surprised by the vibrancy of the 04 Cobalt Blue shade. The color applies smoothly with good pigmentation and adds a fun pop of color without looking overly dramatic. It glides on easily along the lash line, wears comfortably throughout the day, and doesn't smudge easily once set. The cobalt blue brightens the eyes and works especially as well as a subtle accent liner for everyday wear or a bold statement look when built up. The pencil format also makes application quick and beginner friendly.

It's a very fun color but it's a little more transparent than I would have liked. It is definitely waterproof, but it's not smudge proof. Overall it's a fun, bold eyeliner that I'll use for special occasions but I'm not sure it'd be a great all day eyeliner.

The application of the eyeliner is smooth and it stays on amazingly. I barely feel the eyeliner and it glides on so well. The packaging of the product is great.

This eyeliner honestly surprised me. It glides on smoothly like butter, and it stays put once you put it on. The white shade really helps make your eyes pop as well. I never found that it irritated my eyes and it stayed on all day. Would highly recommend.