this eyeline ris amazing and since i wear it alot it works fine if u dont retract too much of it out and it glides like butter if u you it right ive been using this since middle school so its been really good and even being in highschool wearing it now it works like a charm

Did the formula change? I've been wearing this eyeliner for over 10 years and it was wonderful. The last two I bought have smudged and not lasted more than 2-3 hours. I used to LOVE this liner, now I need to try others because I'm looking like a raccoon more often than not.

An apology: I left a negative review of the Infallible eyeliner a while ago which I need to retract. I had a couple of pencils in which the material was hard and failed to adhere smoothly, but it now seems likely that it was the fault of the retailer, and not the product, as the newest pencil I'm using works beautifully as advertised. i will definitely keep using Infallible.

"Infallible" used to be a wonderful liner which was dependable for the life of the product. However, the formula must have been changed, because the last four Matte-Magic eyeliners I've purchased have worked for me perfectly for just the first few applications, smoothly defining a line exactly where I want it, but after about a week, the tip became hard and would not leave even a trace of color!

I wanted to love this eyeliner because I love how navy eyeliner looks but it didn't last half the day much less 16 hours as they claimed. Waste of money!

Love this product easy yo use stays on all day & it has a built in sharpener . Most eyeliners break iff at tip , this doesnt

I was really excited to try this eye liner as I love gel based liners. The first issue is that the color goes on extremely thick in my opinion. So no big deal, I can thin it by using a q-tip. The real issue is how easily it smudges. After about two hours (sometimes not even), I get almost a double line or what looks like raccoon eyes. I've tried using it several different times and unfortunately this happens every single time. I'm tossing this as I'm tired of having to correct my eyeliner every hour.

I've used this eye liner and Color a long time ever since I noticed black was no longer appealing for older eyes. It is creamy enough to go on smooth but strong enough to STAY ON . The longevity is outstanding. The look is natural with a pop ! Highly recommend

I love this eyeliner, the only one I will wear. I wish I could find it in waterproof again.

I'm not sure why this has received such bad reviews. It's awesome, goes on so smooth and stays on for 2 days if I don't wash it off. I don't want to bad reviews to get it discontinued or have the formula changed, because it's THE BEST.