I've been using this mascara for a few years now. It definitely is vibrant and it does the trick. I'm not gonna say it's premium sometimes I do have to reapply and every now and then it does feel a little bit clumpy at the end of the day but for $10-$15…. I love it. I have another one that I buy for $35 and it definitely lasts longer but I keep going back to this one cause it's so much cheaper and it doesn't look any different. It just doesn't last quite as long. I'd rather reapply than spend a ton more money.

I have used this product for the last 8 to ten years. Clumps constantly fall in my eyes,hard to remove, and my eyelashes has never been so sparse since using this. Why would you switch a perfectly good product to this garbage ???

Great mascara, no clumping, but I will be throwing my barely used tube in the garage! Good luck getting it off! Lost lashes trying, save your money and your lashes, avoid this formula.

I've worn this mascara for more than 15 years. I used to love it, but the formula sees to have changed. It has big clumps and it flakes, so I'm looking for another brand. I have very sensitive eyes, and my eyes water, so I need a waterproof mascara, for sensitive eyes.

Ne dépensez pas votre argent pour le mascara bourgogne. Normalement, je porte noir et on n'y voit aucune différence. Il faut être collée au miroir pour constater que c'est légèrement différent. J'aurais préféré que ce soit aussi visible que le mascara bleu que portaient nos tantes lorsqu'on était jeunes.

I loved the original formula of this mascara and used it for years, but now they have changed it and it's horrible! Please change it back or I will have to find another brand.

Love this mascara its not clumpy, doesn't flake or stick your eyelashes together which is a must for me and my eyelashes looked so long and full with this mascara. DEFINITELY recommend 👌

I have been purchasing this mascara for many many years. I have very sensitive skin and eyes and always found this mascara to be a good match for me. It wasn't until recently that I purchased a new one and have been experiencing itchy red and swollen eyes after applying this mascara. I couldn't understand why this was happening until I came on here and it looks like the formula has changed. While I understand formula changes happen for a variety of reasons hopefully you will strongly consider the feedback that's been shared below and take appropriate action.

Why change a product that was great and loved by many? I have been using L'OREAL Voluminous mascara for over 20 years and it was the best for my sensitive skin. I can no longer use it now that the formula has changed. It is causing burning and redness and eyelash loss. What have you done? Bring back the original formula.

I usually just buy this mascara in the regular black waterproof but I decided to try the carbon black this time. It still looks very very good on the lashes but transfers pretty badly on top my brow bone and under my bottom lashes which has never happened with the regular waterproof black.