Bought the charcoal colour. Similar to Heather, at first I didn't realize you have to screw the lid back on and then twist to raise and sharpen the tip. Worked well.

I feel bad for Heather and her review thinking the tiny point is all the product you get LOL you have to turn it up from the base, and twist the cap to sharpen. Glides on and stays put!

This is my favourite eyeliner and I have tried many. I find it very easy to work with, easy to keep sharp and the colours are great!

I found it works well and last a good amount of time. I have the blue, charcoal, green, and brown. I live that it self sharpens. Tough to get cap back off sometimes though.

Awful product. Lady assured me it was a full crayon. WRONG Just like Annabelle, it was only a little tiny point of crayon, which ran out immediately. Not at all worth it!!!!!!

I don't usually write reviews but this one needs to be voiced. It does not sharpen but worse, it lasted 4 times of light application for a work look. I just cannot think who would dare to make a product like that.

Beautiful spruce green color. Love that it self sharpens. Thought I found one of my favorite go to eye pencils but after 2 weeks of use it ran out. So disappointing and I will not be buying again, it's far too expensive for so little product inside and should be lasting a couple months or so. Too bad because it's a nice idea and beautiful color.

It was too dull and really dry my eyes got pretty dry after

I thought that this would be an ideal eyeliner - waterproof and never needing sharpening. Sadly, it was very disappointing as it self sharpens but never to a point. If you are ok with a rounded tip then it'll be ok BUT it also is very dry and does not apply smoothly. There are better choices out there!