I've gone through so many tubes of this and I keep coming back for more. I have short lashes that are full and tend to get clumped together with most mascaras. But because this one has a spiky wand rather than a fluffy brush, it does an excellent job of defining my lashes with no clumping. It's not waterproof, so I wouldn't recommend it for a humid day or an occasion when you may get emotional. But otherwise this is a workhorse, go-to every day mascara that can be wiped off easily at the end of your day without excessive rubbing. Bonus that this brand is not tested on animals, so win win. Highly recommend!

I like the wand, it's similar shape to Benefits Bad gals but more bulkier. Good separation and no spider legs like lashes. It definitely make my lashes look longer. I have straight asian lashes, and anything none waterproof can't hold a volume, but this does hold some volume.

I liked how it made my lashes look, but nothing like wow. And literally within the hour of applying it, I went and looked in the mirror and it had flaked all over my face! Never had issues with flaky mascara until I tried this one. And after one hour? This formula is way too dry. I'm disappointed. Time to go back to L'Oréal.