I love this skinny eyeliner for tightlining and creating a very thin line at the base of my lashes. I love the casing for this as the tube is flush with the pencil as you click it up to advance it, which prevents the pencil from wiggling around and breaking. Keep in mind that you should only advance the pencil a little at a time because you can't wind it back into the tube. This shade of brown is deep enough to create definition, but not as harsh as a black line. It doesn't smudge on me, even when I use it to tightline. I almost exclusively use this liner now for when I want that thin, natural definition.

Way overpriced for what it delivers: kind of dry and dragging, not a clean sharp edge. Also annoying: product clicks up, but now down so any still sticking up get crushed by the cap. Feels like a waste of money :( I expected actual gel, not softer pencil