I really wanted to love this, (as I love the quality of all my other Marcelle products) but there is nothing to love about this eyeliner. It disappears after only a couple of hours. Being waterproof, I assumed it would last until I washed it off. Unfortunately, I would NOT recommend, nor will I continue to use the one I started. I'll be returning to my tried and true, long lasting Revlon Colorstay liner.

Recently discovered Marcelle products. A beauty advisor suggested I try the waterproof velvet gel eyeliner. It is the BEST eyeliner I have ever used, hands down. Creamy, no tugging, perfect, easy to apply and waterproof. Unbelievable. I decided to try their liquid makeup (where have you been all my life?????) and their mascara. OMG. The makeup glides on, but feels feather light, great coverage, and looks great the moment you apply it till the end of a long day! The mascara is spectacular. My usual mascara is Lancôme and this one beats it all over. Plus the quality feels great and you can't beat the price. A Canadian company to boot. Love all you do Marcelle.....now please keep producing these fine products.

I have severe allergies and decided to try this. I have a terrible time trying to get it to go on. It tugs at your eyelid and you have to keep going over it to get a smooth, solid line. It stays on and doesn't smudge once it's there. That is good. It doesn't bother me at all, also good. Application - meh. Will continue looking for something else. I prefer a liquid but like a pencil if it's easy.

Bought mulberry, it is the perfect colour for my hazel eyes, so many compliments! Waterproof as promised and super long wear, gorgeous pigment and creamy enough to get a precise line. LOVE IT!

Ce n'est pas un mauvais crayon, mais la couleur n'est pas assez pigmentée à mon goût et le crayon est un peu trop sec. Je veux une ligne noire et non grise foncée! Par contre, la tenue est excellente. Ma quête afin de trouver un crayon noir qui tient toute la journée, qui à la bonne texture et surtout qui est le plus noir possible continue!

I bought this a couple weeks ago and I love it! It doesn't smudge at all! Which was a hug issues with all the previous eyeliners that I've tried before.

I love everything about this crayon, the ease to use, if feels soft and creamy, it lasts all day and the price.

J'achète ce crayon depuis plus de 10 ans et j'ai toujours été très satisfaite.

I love this product coz i can wear it all day long .

Marcelle has always been one of my favorite brands and never lets me down .Im so happy I got this eyeliner it's SUPER LONG LASTING and dose not smudge one bit .This is the only eyeliner that I've seen that dose what it claims to do ,it's super amazing and would buy again