Day one with this mascara and it leaves black lines all on upper eyelid in spite of having primer, eyeshadow and powder on. Others do not do this. Back to Maybelline Sky High.

Took a chance on this in my quest for a true waterproof mascara that's not messy, goes on like regular mascara, and makes the lashes pop. I was surprised how nicely it covered all my lashes and made them quite full, given it's a narrower brush wand than I'm used to. Mascara stays put, doesn't hit the lids while loading the lashes, and has been easy to remove. I haven't tested it for swimming yet. Loving it so far!

This is my go-to macará! No clumps or wearing off onto your lids.

I've been looking for a waterproof mascara that would also have a small brush (I have fine blonde eye lashes). This mascara just about fit the bill, the only thing is the brush is not as small as I'd like it but works well any way.

This mascara will not come off or smudge, not even a little. It goes on well and stays supple too. It actually does hold the curl very well. I'm glad I gave this mascara a try.

Stays put all day even after the gym and a shower!