It doesn't work as they say, every time I put it on it is very sticky and my eyes sting.

It's the best mascara ever, it's my third time buying it and I love it all day long my lashes look amazing and it does an amazing job

Great "drugstore" mascara! Brush shape is great for lifting and curling the lashes for opening the eyes. Gives the appearance of bigger eyes. The formula is on the drier side, so doesn't clump during application, however, there is a little bit of flaking throughout the day. Easy removal. Love this mascara!

Everytime I wear this my eyes burn and water!! Painful!

I am still truly amazed by this mascara after years of using it! I just went to the Sky Lagoon in Reykjavik and it resisted the whole ritual: warm lagoon; dry spa; mist shower; humid spa and multiple showers! On top of making my eyes pop out thanks to the beautiful lashes it gives, I know I can rely on it to last the whole day! Thanks Maybelline!

I thought I'd try it and I absolutely adore it!! I have short lashes and they are not dark, this gave me longer thicker and just lovely looking lashes and it didn't transfer onto my eyelids where you normally would put your eyeliner, love the formula and the look, even the packaging is pretty! Don't you guys discontinue this or I'm going to have to fly out to New York and have a talk with your creative and marketing team!! Lol

After trying endless high end and drugstore mascaras, this is far and away the best. I used this for my wedding a few years ago after trying to find the best, but forgot to repurchase when I eventually ran out. Instead I wasted time and money on various high end mascaras for years that just didn't perform as well, until I bought this again on a whim and was blown away. I have short, straight lashes that I curl every day, and this is the best mascara for my lashes. Please never discontinue this, but I'd love to see it in burgundy or brown!

I love this mascara!! It's just as good as Too Faced better than sex mascara. Just wish it came in brown shade and I question why the waterproof has a brown black but not the regular. I'm Blonde and fair and prefer brown mascara. So that's why I give it 4 stars

This is a very good mascara and the wand is good but there is always like fuzzy strings on the wand itself and on my eyelashes which then gets into my eye and I can not get it out and it is very annoying, and if its in my eyelashes and try to pull it, it gets all ruined!

The mascara separates my eyelashes and goes on nice. I like the long handle. Very easy to remove