I really really like the contour shade in the colour FAIR, I find it blends out well and goes well with my paler skintone. However the highlighter is far too dark, yellow and shimmery. I have a stack of sticks of just highlighter in my vanity because I only ever use the contour and it feels awful to waste half the product even though I won't use it. Why won't NYX do just a cream contour on it's own?? They all come in some sort of duo/trio. I miss the days of the cream-pro palettes where you could just buy what you needed. The buttermelt bronzers all have a shimmer to them and I can't even use one of their concealers in a darker shade because they're all far too warm-toned.

Great product, excellent on mature skin. Blends in seamlessly

Bring back the old formula! I can't stress this enough! The OG wonder stick was a staple in my makeup collection/bag. The moment I used it, I fell in love with it so much!! Everyone use to always tell me how great it looked on my skin. I then recommended for years and years! I am finally done with the OG wonder stick only bc I had so much back up. And now I am disappointed in the new one because it is no where near the same! Please stop changing out your most popular picks! And bring the old one back. Why are y'all always switching out your most wanted items?!?!?!

I'm disappointed that the highlighter settles in the pores of my nose.

The highlight is quite good. The other end is way too red

I got the fair shade and the colors were *nothing* like the picture. The dark shade was orange and the light shade was yellow.

I loved the OG Wonder stick in Universal. It was truly a Wonder stick at a good price. Now there are many choices. After reading advice, I chose the Universal Light to replace the once perfect Universal. The color is not the same and not good for me. But the biggest problem is that they have changed the formula and IT DOES NOT BLEND INTO THE SKIN. NOt even with brushes or sponges. This turned the wonder stick into something useless. I will have to return it, if nothing else than to make a point. I don't understand why when companies have a product that is a big hit, they change it. Who makes those crazy decisions? Sure, add more colors to include all skin tones. but WHY change the formula?

I am so sad that they got rid of the old light/medium shade, it was the perfect cool-toned contouring stick. And why is the concealer side now a glitter? I've tried multiple different shades of the new formula and none of them are a good match for the old light/medium. I wish they would bring it back!

Product was nice to apply and blended well, but it still wasn't pale or cool toned enough for me personally

As a pale girly I LOVE the cool tone of the contour side, but the highlight side is WAY too yellow and dark in comparison. The formula for the contour shade itself is lovely - goes on smoothly, blends out nicely, not too oily, not too dry (I have the blush sticks that I find dry and very hard to blend). I really wish they would just offer individual cream contour/blush/highlight pans so we can mix and match. I currently have 3 of these dual ended sticks sitting in my vanity with an empty contour side and a full highlight side. I can't bear to throw them out because it feels wasteful. Just let people build their own face pallets.