I've used both this and Stellar Gaze and both are good non-waterproof mascaras. Separates and lengthens while providing a nice, dark black color. Your call as to which mascara you like the most--I've never been disappointed by Pacifica, and I buy a lot of their products. : )

Use daily. Yes the applicator is weird and there is a slight white tinge to your lashes until it dries but ... it's an inexpensive product for strengthening and lengthening. I love it!

I was really disappointed with this mascara. Well specifically the applicator. Instead of "fluffy" I get extra clumpy and end up with 4-5 big thick clumps of lashes. I have been searching for another mascara since the brown mascara was discontinued. This is the second mascara I've tried and the applicators have been a huge disappointment. Maybe the actual mascara is good... I'll have to try applying it with an applicator from a different mascara.

I use this without mascara to keep my lashes healthy. I apply this morning and night. Love that it's vegan, and it dries clear!

I really like this mascara. The brush is fabulous. It lengthens my lashes. My eyes sting a bit when I first put it on. I would like it if it came in brown.

Love this mascara. I've been looking a a better product than drugstore brand. Hate that I have to pay shipping so I have to buy in bulk. Thickens lashes and does not clump per se. Does dry out fast. Wish it were a little more moist. Washes off easily. Does not flake. Love it.

I love this mascara. It makes my lashes fluffy and bold without flaking and is easy to come off at the end of the day.

This is my all-time favorite mascara! My lashes look thick and long without being clumpy at all. It holds up all-day, I never need to reapply, and it washes off easily with warm water. I have sensitive skin and have been using Vegan Collagen Fluffy Lash Mascara without any issues at all. Highly recommend!

This mascara works great for me. The brush stays neat and doesn't cause clumping. The formula adds nice length to my lashes. The cherry on top is that it is easy to wash off.

The mascara is fine. The problem is the wand. I've now had 2 wands break, where the brush part snaps off in the tube of mascara and you can't get it out. Brand new tubes too.