I have had a pretty good time with this mascara! It makes my lashes look longer and darker and fuller. VERY waterproof, I have had many tears but it didn't move at all. It does get clumpy but I use another little brush to even it out.

One thing is true, it will never come off. But then, it will never come off. I tried everything for four days and finally, it gave up. Meanwhile, I looked like hot garbage for four days because my lashes all clumped together into 3 big eyelashes. It was awful. Also, trying to get it off damaged my skin at the eyelash line... my eyelid was bleeding trying to gently rub it off by the fourth day. No bueno.

I purchased this mascara after over 10 years of supporting Pacifica's products. I adore everything they make and I'm devastated that this particular product is so terrible. While it is most certainly waterproof, it will NOT come off. I used makeup removers (both oil based and not). It took a week to get 80% of it off. And I had to stop trying to get the other 20% of it off because my eye started BLEEDING! And I was incredibly gentle with the removal process. I agree with the other reviewers here and it is very hard to get off of your skin or anything else it gets on. The wand is weird but it did make my eyelashes look good for the first few hours. As the week went on, my plethora of eyelashes clumped together into 3 clumps along each eye. I'll never put this on my eyes again and can't believe I gave it a second chance application (I've put it on twice to make sure it wasn't a *me* thing). On top of that, I wrote a very kind message to the company to let them know about what the product did to me and that it physically harmed me and the reply was "how to remove it" and how much "she loves" the product. How is that a reply to someone who was physically harmed by your product? I'm incredibly disappointed by all of this because Pacifica is my go-to for makeup.

The wand is a bad twisted shape that doesn't allow for even application. Also the formula too waterproof compared to Aquarian gaze.

Surf Lash mascara - when applying if you get any little smudge on your skin it is very challenging to get off. Doesn't ever seem to dry, sneeze and now you have back smudges under your eyes that you cannot gt off. Applicator brush is fine I have used Pacifica Aquarian Gaze mascara for years and loved it , but can no longer get. Bummed.

Let me reiterate: bring back Aquarian Glaze!!! This one gets on my brow bone and under eyes yet will not budge when you try to remove it. Truly worst of both worlds! Sure, my lashes look FULL but the people buying your products are natural girlies. AG was the perfect mascara. Natural build able look, stays on, easy to remove.

This just doesn't compare. Wanted to try it because it claims to be waterproof, but I just can't. I'll be switching brands unfortunately.

Not a fan at all of this new waterproof (not) mascara. Aquarian Gaze was my day time go to. Please bring it back.

It's great for lash definition with my thin and sparse lashes however I truly prefer the other waterproof mascara and mascara wand and am disappointed that it continues to be out of stock.

Please bring back Aquarian gaze!!!! This mascara is horrid and the twisted brush make it impossible to coat lashes and make a mess. So bad!