Please bring this back! Even if it's the new lip liner formula. I love it in Safeword. For those that think it doesn't work once the tip is gone, I wonder if they realize they need to put the cap back on and unscrew it so it will advance and resharpen. Sometimes if you use the whole tip you have to do that a couple of times in a row. But that's still better than dealing with a pencil sharpener. Just think of how many times the tip breaks when you use those anyways. I need to get the reds to match the new legendary lipstick in It's a Mood, and even Bawse.

I love Always Sharp Lip Liner - I use the Crimson most often. I am extremely busy and I prefer this to sharpening a lipliner. Plus, the colour is amazing.

So many reviews mention that the twist-up function doesn't work. The only part of this liner designed to twist is the cap. To advance more product, you need to grip the top (liner end) of the pencil between your pointer finger & thumb and push back toward the end of the pencil. When you release, a small amount of product extends past the tip. I bought the color Sienna, which is no longer available. Good consistency and long-wearing. I bought it at a discount store, so the small amount I paid makes it especially worthwhile. Not sure I would pay full price.

I can't believe how fraudulent the product is. I bought It 2 days ago and is all gone. For my surprise the lip you get is the tip you see when you buy it. That is all!! Sooo bad really

This lip liner is great until you extend it - looks like it is a long pencil but the refill inside is non existent . So disappointing .

I bought the product a couple weeks ago and tried to extend the crayon but either it's all gone or it's broken. I think it's all gone. All you get is the tip you see when you buy it. Certainly not even close to the dollars paid.

I've been utilizing these liners for years. As of late they have less and less product and all my fave colors have been discontinued. Bring them back. Lower the price and add more product.

I must be missing something because the few mm you can see is all there is. It lasts about 4 weeks. Don't know why the case is so long. It looks like the top should turn to wind it up but nothing happens.I love the actual product but not the quantity

I used to use and love the smashbox lip liner in pencil form. In fact, when it was discontinued I bought every one I could find. Alas, I've used them all up and decided to try this self-sharpening version. It is not good. First, the cap fits on so tightly that it takes great force to pull it off daily. Several times this force has cause the liner to break off, wasting product!! Second, at a time when most companies are focused on sustainability and reducing product waste,smashbox has elected to place this product in MORE plastic and wasteful packaging. A pencil gets smaller as you use it up, making it lightweight and compact for travel. This large plastic applicator takes up space no matter how much you use up. with a pencil you can also customize the tip to create the line you like: fat or thin. This automatic pencil only gives you the option of a thin line. I use the smashbox liner as a grippy base for my lip products so I like a fat tip for faster filling. The liner itself is great but I won't be buying again in this packaging.

I bought this product less than a month ago and it is already out or it's not working. I like the color but that is it.