The mascara is actually clumpy and gives me spider lashes. It also actually flakes like throughout the day. Instead of giving me clean, separated, fanned out lashes, it makes my lashes stick together and look messy. The flaking is especially bad because I end up with mascara particles all underneath my eyes. Definitely not worth it.

It's just like other mascara's some clump, flake other don't. It is more expensive than another brand I love. I am just going to by my original brand. No big deal here for me, except cost. Not as waterproof as I would like it to be either. I swim and it smears in pool water. Buy at your own risk and if you love it... Great.

I've tried so many mascaras, drugstore and high end. (Was using Benefit Bad Girl Bang - I didn't like it, it flaked, irritated my eyes and took ages to remove). I then tried this mascara it is amazing, lovely separated lashes, no clumping, lightweight, lasts all day and doesn't flake, it's easy to use. It's the best, love the look and will continue to buy it. Hopefully they don't change the formula, Another great product from Smashbox!

I got stuck overnight in an airport due to weather. I finally got to my destination the next afternoon (well over 24 hours since I put on the mascara) and my lashes were still perfection - no flaking or raccoon eyes! I buy it for all my friends and family. Just brush your lashes if you see clumps upon applicatoin.

I had breast cancer and did chemo 7 years ago. My eyelashes grew back but are nothing like they were before. They are shorter and straight. No curl at all. I miss my old lashes!! Super Fan is the first mascara I have found that separates and curls my upper lashes. They look more like my lashes before cancer and the awful chemo happened. I don't have to use an eyelash curler or anything. I'm very happy with this product and love when they have the smaller travel size of Super Fan available.

This is the most expensive mascara Ive ever purchased and it is by far the worst. It clumps terribly and does not fan my eyelashes like it promotes itself to do. I cannot even continue to use it.

I bought this last year as I loved the mini sample I was given. The full size product is clumpy and I've thrown it away. I read another review saying exactly the same and wish I had listened.

I got this maybe 4 years ago and am now buying a new one. It last long and I love the brush. Overall a great mascara

This is about the worst mascara I have ever used. Clumpy, flaked. It was awful.

I had a mini size and loved it so was confident enough to treat myself to a full size,however was very disappointed as it was clumpy from the get go,ended up throwing it away !