What a waste of money. Way to thick and clumpy. Does not even spread across eyelid evenly.

Purchased this eyeshadow primer after my older one ran out, unaware that the formula changed even though the packaging was way different. Previous left my eyeshadow always beautiful for hours despite me having oily eyelids. This new one makes my eyeshadow terrible after 30 minutes. Completely not gripping at all. Return back to the old formula. People are out here purchasing the older formulas on different websites.

I have bought the original eyeshadow primer for years and love it . You could sleep with your makeup on and look great in the morning. For some reason they decided to change the packaging and product. Now it is terrible. It doesn't last and it gets gritty during the day.Please go back to the original one.

The old formula was my holy grail! It was the only thing that would work with my oily lids. Please bring back the old formula. The new one does not work at all…BRING BACK THE OLD FORMULA BACK! PLEASE!!!

Please bring back the old primer. This is thick and sticky and eyeshadow goes on poorly. It's really a disappointment

I still think that this is the best eye primer around. Yes, it's a little more difficult to get out of the tube, and, yes, it's a little thicker. I simply warm it between my ring fingertips before applying and it goes on really smoothly. I flew overnight with my eye makeup on and it didn't budge. It's the only one that I have found that keeps my eyeshadows where I put them. With other primers it'll my shadows just blend together.

Is this product that is supposed to replace the Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer? Poor substitute if it is. If it isn't then where is the under eye primer?

Still the only eye primer that won't crease on my oily lids. I was afraid to try the new formulation because of all the bad reviews, but they were so completely wrong. I agree the packaging is difficult, but I'm never using another brand again.

After using Smashbox eyelid primer for years, I was deeply disappointed after trying the new formula. It feels lumpy; not silky like the other formula and my eyeshadow ends up under my eyes. It is NOT wearproof or sweatproof, does not last,and feels rough on my eyelids. I used to be able to skydive, swim, and mow the lawn with the previous one. This one is just a huge waste of money! Bring back the old version, so I don't have to look for another brand!

I loved the original primer! Everyone always asked what I was wearing. The new one now is not at all the same. So dissatisfied that you would change a product that was so good. I really tried to give the new one a chance but no way is this anywhere like the original. Will never understand why you would change something so good. Now on to finding a new one! Unless you bring the old one back!! Very disappointed! Would not recommend