Too Faced

Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer

Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer
  • Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer 1
  • Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer 2
  • Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer 3
  • Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer 4
  • Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer 5
  • Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer 6

Too Faced

Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer

$41

$41

Plus tax

615 PC Optimum points

Colour: Translucent

Quantity

1

Shipping

Shipping

-

Available at select locations.

Bopis

Pickup

-

Available at select stores.

Same Day Delivery

Same-day delivery

-

Available at select locations.

Price, promotions, and stock availability subject to change. $8 fee applies to shipping orders below $35. Pickup times vary. *A government mandated bag fee of up to $0.75, based on your province and selected store applies to pickup orders. Fees appear at checkout.

Offers for this product (1)

    3 free samples

    Choose 3 free samples at checkout for Luxury Beauty purchase.

About this product

Item #651986200733

Too Faced Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer delivers crease-proof, waterproof, and fade-resistant wear for over 24 hours. This iconic primer intensifies eyeshadow color and locks it in place, ensuring your look remains vibrant and true from application to removal. The lightweight, translucent formula glides on weightlessly and is suitable for all skin tones, creating a smooth canvas for both powder and cream shadows. Formulated with an easy-blend doe-foot applicator, it also helps to fight oil and protect skin from blue light damage, keeping your eyeshadow flawless.

Review Snapshot

4.1
791 ReviewsWrite a review
12%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend

Ratings Distribution

Most Liked Positive Review

Shadow Insurance

I wasn't sure what to expect when I bought this product, as I've never used any kind of primer before. While I've worn makeup on and off since I was a teen, I've never worn more than eyeliner and a simple shadow. I've only very recently begun experimenting with blending together more than one shadow...

Versus

Most Liked Negative Review

Best formula - unforgivable new packaging

I have used this primer faithfully since it was featured in the Spring 2011 Prom edition of Seventeen magazine. Many brands and products have come and gone in my makeup bag over the years, but this one was a staple for nearly 15 years — until now. The re-packaging destroyed the formula. It dries the...

Reviewed by 791 customers

Shadow Insurance packaging

Submitted 1 month ago

By Kathy

From United States

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I absolutely LOVE Shadow Insurance. I'm an international flight attendant and routinely work 18-19 hour days. My eye shadow stays in place the whole time! BUT…..this new packaging is awful. I cannot control how much product comes out and I never k ow how much I have left. PLEASE bring the squeeze tube back.

Was this review helpful to you?

Bring back the OLD FORMULA and TUBE!

Submitted 2 months ago

By Shanny730

From United States

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I just bought this and the formula definitely has CHANGED, It doesn't work now. It used to be one of my favorite products when it was in the tube. I'm now searching for a new product from another company. My picture shows the old tube (the word SHADOW has rubbed off because I had it so long) I'm very disappointed in the new product formula, it doesn't work and it's a waste of money. I wouldn't recommend it at all, don't waste your money.

User submitted media
Old tube worked

Bottom Line No, I would not recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

Change back to previous packaging!

Submitted 2 months ago

By Zyas

From LAUREL MD

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

Please change this back to the squeeze tube. This is the best product ever. However the problem is it's very difficult to tell when you're about to run out because you can't see how much is left. It's also somehow more dry than it used to be when it was in the Squeeze tube. Also the applicator is not useful because you still have to use your fingers to spread it over your eyelids evenly.

Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

Great formula, packaging is a dealbreaker

Submitted 4 months ago

By Rancidoreo

From Canada

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I've repurchased this primer because the formula is genuinely excellent — it keeps my eyeshadow locked in place all day, whether I'm dealing with normal wear or extreme heat/humidity. No creasing, no fading, no fallout. On performance alone, this is a 5-star product. But the new packaging has been a real letdown. This is my second purchase, and both times the lid has cracked and broken — even with careful opening, closing, and application. I really miss the old squeeze tube; it was sturdy and never gave me issues. I want to keep buying this, but the packaging failures are making me reconsider. Please bring back the squeeze tube, or fix the lid design — the formula deserves better packaging.

Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

Won't repurchase due to new packaging

Submitted 4 months ago

By Skye

From Australia

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

This primer was my holy grail, I probably purchased over 10 tubes in my time using it. I tried the doe foot applicator version once and have never repurchased. Leaving a comment now because I periodically check to see if it has been changed back, and am always disappointed! The squeeze component was more slim lined, you had more control on the amount that you used, and it lasted longer. Not to mention the new tube just falls apart... I have still, after years, not found a product that I liked better than this in the squeezy tube. Such a disappointment.

Bottom Line No, I would not recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

Bring Back Prior Version New Applicator is Difficult and Dry

Submitted 10 months ago

By Zebsmom

From Texas

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I just purchased my second tube of the new version of Shadow Insurance, at Ulta. The new, tube packaging with applicator has ruined the application experience, of the product. It is difficult to use and feels much drier. The prior version was quick and easy to apply--virtually foolproof. This applicator can also leave splotches, where too much product is dispensed by the wand, leaving the user to still need to smooth the product with their fingertips. I thought i would gamble on purchasing my once favorite product again, but to my dismay, it still disappoints. Please bring back the prior version. The packaging was smaller too and better for travel. I am sad that I need to find a different product to replace this. In the past, I recommended it to all. People were amazed to see me emerge from my swimming pool with my eyeshadow still in place, thats how good this was. I think the company should take note of the numerous like-minded reviews of this product, not just here, but other sites. Your decades long customers have spoken up.

Was this review helpful to you?

New dispenser/Doesn't Work!!!!!!!

Submitted 10 months ago

By Joslyn

From La Jolla, California

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I loved the old product in a tube and was a die heart loyalist. The new wand dispenser is horrible. The consistency has changed, it's difficult to get out of the cylinder, doesn't apply well, is sometimes watery and overall doesn't work. I'm on the hunt for a new product from a different company.

Bottom Line No, I would not recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

Amazing product / terrible package

Submitted 11 months ago

By Ana

From Portugal

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I love this product, but every time I buy it, the cover breaks. You should challenge some of your engineers on packaging concepts — it's just not normal.

User submitted media 1 of 2
cap2
User submitted media 2 of 2
cap

Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

Won't buy again

Submitted 1 year ago

By LB

From United States

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

This is the best eye primer I've used but the old packaging needs to come back. Like many of the other reviews this new packaging is horrible. Produce dried out and the lid cracks. Thought it was a fluke but it happened again and I came here to see if it's just me but no. Going to switch to something else until I see a change has been made. I hoping for it!

User submitted media 1 of 2
User submitted media 2 of 2

Bottom Line No, I would not recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?

So disappointed with how it's packaged now

Submitted 1 year ago

By Lilaq

From California

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

toofaced.com/

I have been a faithful user of this product for years. I started using it because I was gifted a small sample of it, and that sample lasted me for over a year with regular use. It's been my holy grail ever since. The product now comes in a bottle with a doe foot applicator, and it's much harder to get the product out of the bottle and it dried up very fast. I didn't even get a year's use out of this, when normally it last over a year (and even my small sample lasted over a year). I don't know if the product has dried up or there is much less present in the bottle now, but I'm not going to spend almost $30 on it now.

Bottom Line No, I would not recommend to a friend

Was this review helpful to you?