This use to be the best mascara out there. Now it's dry and flaky. I thought maybe I just got an old one. But got 2 more and the same. Dry dry

I want to love the Better Than Sex mascara; it does add nice volume and fullness but it smudges like crazy throughout the day. I'll stick to tubing mascara.

I have been a loyal user of this product for three years and recommend it to all my friends. I am based in Australia. However, the new tube I received seems to take forever to dry - up to half an hour where if I blink I am left with embarrassing blotches of black under my eyes and on my cheeks. This has never been the case before. I wonder if you have changed the formula? Thank you, Helen

Very disappointed in this product. It arrived seemingly dry and clumpy on the wand, which resulted in clumpy lashes. The mascara has an odor that is bothersome to me (I'm sensitive to smells), and it ended up flaking off as the day went on. I wouldn't recommend this product.

Liked the mascara but much too hard to get off...

I've tried this so many times and every single time it's just made my lashes stubby, short, and clumpy (all things I, personally don't want from a mascara). Every coat I apply makes it worse, it always ends up looking like my eyelashes, only worse.

Their OG mascara is the best looking mascara i've ever used but it kept smudging all around my eyes so i returned it and bought the waterproof to see if it will prevent that. it's literally worse. the actual lashes look bomb but no one looks good with raccoon eyes and it will keep smearing no matter how many times you clean it up throughout the day. idk if it's a formula change issue or what but i hope they fix it. disappointed and will be returning

I've used this mascara for over 10 years and loved it; however, I decided to try the waterproof to prevent smudging. What a disappointment! Within an hour or two I had black raccoon eyes, especially on the bottom. I don't understand how a product that is to be waterproof can smudge so quickly. I guess I will give the regular product one more try. But…if I can find another mascara that gives me the same volume on my old, scarce lashes, I will switch in a minute.

Better than sex? I understand that we are living in a much more liberal world and sex well may not mean much anymore, but I don't care if this mascara made my eyelashes go all the way up my forehead, there has never and will never be a time that mascara is better than sex with my husband. I do recognize that we may be running out of names for product as there is an abundance of them out there, but this is just not true. As for the mascara, it does the job, but the name…we can do better. 🫣

Definitely my favorite mascara! I always get compliments on it and sometimes people ask if I'm wearing fake eyelashes.