I have used the normal version of the better than sex mascara for years. I decided to try out the waterproof variant since I do have very watery eyes and would often get some bleeding from my mascara by the end of the day. With the waterproof stuff I don't have that issue now. Unlike the bad reviews I have seen on here I haven't had issues with clumping, although I use a lash primer so that probably helps. I also find the little water droplets on the container cute I like the packaging, I like the product. The shape the wand is great I always have issues with other style of wands and stabbing myself in the eyelid or eyeball with them, for some reason this style works for me.

This is nowhere near waterproof. I tried it as soon as I got home from work and by bedtime I had smudges. Tried it again the next day and same thing. For staying power, it's worse than a regular mascara like the benefit rollerball. It also seemed very dry, and didn't do much for my lashes. I curled them before applying and it actually seemed to make them go straight again. It was not thickening or lengthening. Very disappointed because it got great reviews. I'm still searching for a great waterproof mascara as nothing seems to stick

Definitely disappointed with this mascara, I don't have long lashes and I thought maybe this brush would be good but absolutely not. It clumped really bad, almost like the mascara was too thick.

My eyelashes are long, but very very straight. The waterproof version keeps my lashes curled all day! I always get asked if I have lash extensions when I wear this.

For waterproof I'm surprised at how bad this smudges and leaves black under my eyes. Especially because I only put it on my top lashes.