Absolutely love this lip liner! 🤍 The formula is smooth, creamy, and glides on effortlessly. It defines the lips perfectly, lasts for hours, and pairs beautifully with any lipstick or gloss. A must-have for everyday makeup! ✨

This eyeliner is horrible! It works great when you initially buy it, but once the tip is gone you better buy a new one. I can't sharpen it to use any more of it. The tip breaks and the plastic is so hard the sharpener can't cut through it before the eyeliner breaks. It has cut my eye several times and I am DONE ever purchasing this again.

I bought 9 eyeliner @ hsn when they were on sale.3 for me 3 for my daughter and 3 for my bestie.@ first they were amazing now they don't even work.i am so upset cause same issue with the sharpening.do I have to get a lighter and burn the end .like we used too back in the 80's

I moisten it & then it glides on extremely easy. The sharpening complaints would apply to most eyeliners. The trick is to not use the sharpener, they seldom work properly. I find it has enough point after each use, & if I must sharpen any eyeliner, I just use a tissue & lightly swirl it around the end. The only con is that it does bleed a bit under the eye on humid days.

I do love: The expresso/dark brown The smooth application, glides right on I Don't love: It is NOT waterproof It does NOT last 36 hours

Whole i absolutely love the liner, wears well and all... the sharpening is infuriating!! You either have to sharpen WAY too far and waste a ton of very expensive product or it leaves insanely sharp points that hurt if they touch your lids!! There really had to be a better design for such a pricey product!!

If it weren't for the plastic casing I would probably be 100% for this product. The plastic casing has caused me to WASTE more product than I'm actually getting to use! I sharpen it and the makeup falls out! So I shove it back in but this plastic casing sharpens to where there are sharp edges that I don't want scraping my eyeballs! Love the liner itself but for how much this pencil costs, it's not worth it.

I was so excited for this color, but I think that I am going to be a mechanical clicky eye and lip liner girl from now on. It's taken me 44 years, but I just cannot do pencils that need sharpened! It's just a pain, Even if you get a good one pretty soon it gets so short. It's difficult to use properly. I could honestly rant for a while about why are we still doing this!? We have to have the technology for clicky and twisty iron lip pencils now! I still had to give it two stars because the color was fabulous the few times I got to wear it! Unfortunately it broke off and so the approximately 2 inches that was in there fell out😭 when I tried to put it back in it was so dried out that it just broke again. I've had a horrible luck with the liners that require sharpening but otherwise I'm Too faced day long!

After all the bad reviews of this product I felt I had to stick up for it. I've been using this liner for 2 or 3 years. I order 2 or 3 at a time. The formula is perfect. It's easy to apply and easy to use a brush with it too. I have zero problems sharpening it. ZERO. I have multiple sharpeners all designed for makeup and I have never had a problem. It doesn't slip out of the casing either. I don't know why others have such a hard time with it.

Love the liner but a major design flaw as you can't easily get more liner without using a manual sharpener on PLASTIC. Wish I could return it. Very wasteful.