I bought this product this weekend and it has seriously burnt my eyes. My eyes have watered for hours after applying it. It doesn't go on well and stays on for less than a minute. It definitely isn't waterproof. A total waste of money.

So smooth and such good pigment doesn't wear off easily as well

I love it and it is so easy to use!!

I've been using this eye liner for 6 or 7 years. Now my eyes burn so severely I am going to switch and try a different brand. My daughter experienced the same issues and switched blood long ago. I was telling her how bad my eyes are lately and she told me what happened to her. You need to fix this. I see other people having same issues.

I have never ever experienced eyeliner burn my eyes like this. I'm not sure what's going on but you all need to fix this immediately. I had to go to the eye doctor over this. At first I thought, no way, I've never had makeup cause me an issue. Nope it was 100% this eyeliner. Wish I saved my receipt.

This was a big disappointment. It smudged almost immediately and is absolutely not waterproof. I thought it'd be worth it to upgrade, but now I wish I'd just stuck to my previous brand, which wasn't perfect, but was definitely better and a third of the price.

BY FAR THIS IS THE BEST EYELINER EVER. I LIVE IN FLORIDA AND THIS IS MY GO TO EVERYDAY, I HAVE TRIED MANY AND THIS ONE IS THE BEST!

Love the better than sex liquid liner in black but for some reason the bristles in the brown color hurt during application.

I've been using this eyeliner since it came out and have never been able to tell if the formula has never changed. I'm so happy with it. It's the easiest application of eyeliner I've ever had and I've been rocking an intense wing since I was 13(I'm 29) I even use the brown shade for my lip liner and I always get compliments on my tik toks of my eyeliner and I always recommend this eyeliner. It's the BEST. I can wear it all day and it's smudge proof and isn't a burden to wash off. Absolutely a staple in my daily make up look.

I used this and it hurts so bad. I felt like I was being scratched with microscopic needles. I thought I had a defective eyeliner until I saw similar reviews. I loved the color, but I don't want to risk an infection or wrinkles on my lid. I'll stick to Stila liquid eyeliner. I like toofaced other products alot, this one was just a hard no go.