Gave me a horrible allergic reaction. My eyes are burning and puffy. Even if this wasn't the case it is not close to waterproof; black under my eyes within an hour. Beyond disappointed.

I think that says enough, but BTS is the only mascara I use now. I just got the the waterproof version, and did a trial run at work. The feels-like temperature was over 100° with a 61% humidity. ((I also sweat a *lot* 😭)) I had ZERO smudging, melting, or even those little mascara-covered eye goobers. Can't recommend enough!!

I bought this because I love the regular and figured the waterproof would be just as amazing. I regret this purchase. It clumps the lashes together so much that it looks awful, looking like there is gaps or bald spots on your lashes. It is such a pain to remove (even with make up removers) which adds to the issue with clumping your lashes together. Don't waste your money on this product. Just buy the regular better than sex mascara and avoid water ha

this mascara leaves black residue everywhere it is not waterproof at all and I am very disappointed with this brand and better than sex range. it does not go to the standard it stated being 'waterproof' I don't think so...

Love this mascara! My only wish is that it was cheaper😔

so i brought this on vacation excited and was very disappointed as the second i went under water it starting turning into a black liquid dripping off my eyelashes to around my eyes. Let's just say it doesn't work

I have used the normal version of the better than sex mascara for years. I decided to try out the waterproof variant since I do have very watery eyes and would often get some bleeding from my mascara by the end of the day. With the waterproof stuff I don't have that issue now. Unlike the bad reviews I have seen on here I haven't had issues with clumping, although I use a lash primer so that probably helps. I also find the little water droplets on the container cute I like the packaging, I like the product. The shape the wand is great I always have issues with other style of wands and stabbing myself in the eyelid or eyeball with them, for some reason this style works for me.

I have been an avid Too Faced mascara user for years. I normally buy the regular Better Than Sex mascara but I seen the waterproof one and thought I would give it a try because my allergies have been flaring up and my eyes have been watering, causing my mascara to run. Day one of putting it on was horrible. It was dry and made my lashes very clumpy and did not give them any length (not like the original). Washing it off is a little tough and took off some lashes while trying to remove the mascara. Day two of applying it, got some on my eyelid (because it was going on clumpy and I was trying to fix it) and I could not get it off of my eyelid without removing everything from that eye!! This mascara does NOT do what is promised. Now I need to decide if I just go back to the original, or find a new line of mascara. VERY DISAPPOINTED!

Absolutely terrible thought I would love this since I love the original better then sex mascara but this is not waterproof so disappointing

I have been using this mascara for years. It is absolutely fantastic. I have used both the waterproof and the non waterproof one. I mostly use the easy to wash off one just because it's easier at the end of the day. I can't believe people don't all like it. Best mascara I've ever used and I've used a lot!