Been using this product for years bought in all colours. Stays on all day without smudging, but volume is very little. Please upsize this product and make more colors.

I was so pleased with the rose metal couple of weeks later I bought the Heavy metal shade. They are easy to apply but sit down and a completely waterproof. This is important to me as I use them under my eyes and on the inner corner so I want longevity and brightness of colour waterproof. I don't wear waterproof make up as a rule.

These are fabulous eyeliners that hold on all day through just about anything yet are fairly easy to remove. Watier is known for the quality and diverse shade selection of liners eye and lip. I got the shades rose metal first then heavy metal beautiful they are. Although they have less product than the pencil liners they have still been lasting well and for lighter shades they work well for daytime looks and there are darker shades as well. I have my eye on the navy one next. Most of my liners of all types are from this brand and all are well made and work beautifully

Bought 4-5 of these by now, overall good and bad. Good: really water proof and color stays on all day without smudging. Bad: navy color breaks VERY easily and quantity is too small for the price.

I have this in rose metal and I love it as an inner corner highlight or undereye liner before a bit of a darker colour. The formula is soft yet stays put and there is a sharpener in the bottom. Mature skin friendly

I bought rose gold and it works terrific for an inner corner highlight as it can be sharpened and it's water resistant much better than shadow alone

This product really does not run! Every other summer while working outside in the heat, my 'waterproof' eyeliner has inevitably ended up in my eyes, causing a burning feeling and a raccoon look. This gel liner is easy to apply and stays on, but washes off easily too. To me, it's worth paying more for something that actually works. It lasts long too!

I bought a 2 nd time in both shades as I can't live without them! A truly exceptional eye product !

I love this eyeliner formula. It is very pigmented, it stays in place all day without smudging and it is waterproof. My complaint with this product is the volume of product in the eyeliner container. The Lise Watier wood eyeliner pencils contain 1.2g of product. This retractable pencil contains 0.5g of product. That is less than half of the product sold in the pencils. I feel like this pencil is a devious way to sell customers less than half the product for the same price. Then you end up purchasing twice as many eyeliners. I recommend the Lise Watier wood pencil eyeliners, but I recommend passing on this particular pencil.

Lovely colour. Dark but not as harsh as black and a little more personality than brown.