Delighted with the quality. I see some others haven't had a good experience but thankful that I did. Got on sale and wanted to try a different brand. Happy with this one, the black is just right, and will likely get this again

Absolute garbage product. After using it twice (bought 24 hours ago) tip has dried out and is basically unusable. Do not buy this eyeliner. Waste of money.

This is a good liquid eyeliner. The pen tip is very thin and stiff, allowing you to easily draw sharp lines. Once dry, this eyeliner does not move. Unfortunately, my pen dried out quickly, making it hard for me to justify the cost. I would only recommend this eyeliner if you use it frequently and will use it up quickly.

I tried this instead of my regular smashbox liquid eye liner (recommended in store). I like the tip better, it makes for a nicer and more controllable application, but the eye liner bleed so easily. I end up with black everywhere around my eyes in no time at all, it's pretty dissapointing.

I tried this when at a shoppers event, because I would never have bought this. I am not an eyeliner girl. Well, now I am. I own this now. This stuff is so easy to put on, and the brush is so thin it's amazing to use. My lines are always clean, and one time I messed up a line, and it was super easy to correct. I love this stuff, and I'll always buy it.

This is by far the worst eyeliner I have ever used. Yes it has a super fine tip but no product gets out there so it's impossible to get a fine line. If you try to do a touch up it blends everywhere.

They have changed the shade so it's less of a dark brown. As well, I've used other brands like Smashbox and one eyeliner lasts me a couple months (with every day applications). I find this one needs replacement much more often. It's great for a natural look but for the price, I would recommend a brand that lasts a bit longer!

My eyelids are really oily, so I have to use primer before I apply eyeliner. Even with primer, this liner does not last half the day. On top of that, the liquid ran out really quickly. The only pro about this product for me, was that the tip is gentler than most liquid eyeliners. It probably will work a little better for people with normal/dry eyelids.